Welcome to the third season of
Once Upon A Time. While they
beat pilots, I'm not particularly fond of season premieres. "The Heart
of the Truest Believer" is an exception. From the cold open, it engaged
me far more than I expected and made me see the show from a fresher
perspective: this show tells Emma's fairy tale.
I'm both sure I'm not the first person to have thought or said so,
and this isn't even the first time I've thought it, but throughout
season 2 I forgot all about it and that's where I think last season
suffered. Emma, who grew up in the stark reality of
Our World is
our gateway to this magical multiverse. When an episode or plot-line
forgets about Emma, it forsakes us. No matter how deliciously devilish
Regina, Rumpy, Cora, etc. can be, no matter how noble Snow and Charming,
no matter how well done flashbacks are, Emma needs to be the heart of
this show, because this is
her story, every bit as much as
Sleeping Beauty is the story of Princess Aurora, or
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is Snow White's.
Once Upon A Time,
in a far away land, a royal family awaited the
birth of their first child... For while the family's bravery and
beneficence inspired both admiration and loyalty among their subjects
and peers, their land was not free from the evil with which even the
best do daily battle. As the child made her very entry into her world,
that world was enveloped by the Dark Curse, cast by a vengeful Queen who
had a generational blood feud against the child's mother -- a feud
contrived by a crafty outsider -- the Dark One -- for a purpose all his
own. Since the royal child was prophesied to be the savior who could
rescue the people from the Dark Curse, the parents -- aided by their
most loyal subjects, and one mostly
loyal subject -- made arrangements to transport their child to a world beyond that curse's reach -- a land without magic.
When this child, a girl, came into the world her parents named her Emma
.
They entrusted the wee princess's safety to an enchanted wardrobe which
transported her out of harm's way -- at least out of the reach of the
Dark Curse. In her new world, the baby was abandoned by the one person
who was supposed to protect her, and was shunted off to the custody of
strangers who were more concerned with their monthly stipend from the
State than with the care and nurture of the princess in their midst.
Though she grew fair in form and face, no one recognized either
Emma's station or strength. No one recognized her innate power which
bubbled up from her very heart. In this land without magic, no one
realized that Emma -- made of true love, herself -- was magic incarnate.
No one saw Emma's worth, until one day she met a man who, unbeknownst
to her, came from her homeland -- a homeland about which she knew
nothing. These two foundlings fell in love and planned for a future in
which they hoped to live happily ever after In a misguided attempt to right the wrong he'd committed when Emma
was just a baby, the person who had once abandoned her, enticed her
true love to also abandon her so that she would be free to fulfill her
destiny. Alone, unjustly imprisoned, and expecting a child of her own,
Princess Emma had to find her way along a path she didn't even know she
existed, which would lead her to worlds she couldn't even imagine. This
is her story. This is Emma's story. Please remember that,
Eleven years ago. Under the watchful eye of a prison guard, Emma
gives birth to her firstborn son at 8:15. The magic that exudes from her
every pore shorts out lights in the delivery room. Knowing she is
unable to give him his best chance at life, she refuses even to hold her
baby for fear that if she does she will never let go. As the doctor
takes the lad away, Emma cries.
Present day. On the Jolly Roger, Captain Hook takes Emma, Snow,
Charming, Regina and Mr. Gold through a magical portal. They arrive off
the shores of Neverland.
Title card.
Henry reaches the end of his own portal, accompanied by the
two-headed plot monster known and Tamara and Greg...Owen...GROAN.
Because Henry knows his family is from the Enchanted Forest, he is
confident they will find him because finding their loved ones is how
they do. The two-headed monster reveals that they are not in the
Enchanted Forest, but rather, Neverland, and they're there to destroy
it, they think, because it is the motherlode of all magic. When they try
to contact the "Home Office" on a handheld device, they fail, because
it is just a prop with sand where the batteries should be. As he's been
doing since they landed, Henry points out how foolish the two-headed
monster has been, in failing to ask questions. There are none so blind
as they who won't see, so the two-headed monster orders the boy to walk
into the jungle. We cut to the...
Jolly Roger. Regina and Hook trade barbs and stories. The irony that
Hook has willingly transported his sworn enemy (Rumpy) back to the place
Hook spent so long trying to leave, is not lost on the sexy
swashbuckler. "It's not quite the happy ending I was hoping for." Regina
mentions that GROAN said something "funny" to her. "He said I'm a
villain, and that villains don't get happy endings. Do you believe
that?" Hook hopes not or they've wasted their lives. Get in line,
Killian.
Snow and Charming approach Emma, who is staring out to sea lost in
her thoughts. They assure her that what happened to Neal and Henry is
not her fault. Snow says, "You can't blame yourself." Face tight, Emma
turns to face her parents. "I don't. I blame you. All this happened
because I listened to you. You say good always wins. It doesn't. I
didn't grow up in some fairy tale land. My experience is different.
That's all I can go on." Snow understands and says all they have to go
on is their own experience, then adds, "So if you would just let us
share our wisdomEmma cuts her off. "I appreciate you trying to be parents, but we're
the same age. We have equal amounts of wisdom. I should never have
broken the curse. I should have just taken Henry and..." Like daughter,
like mother. Snow interrupts and acknowledges the truth in Emma's words.
After all, she and Charming missed their chance to rear Emma, and it
haunts them still. Charming assures his daughter they'll reunite their
family. Emma is put off by their optimism and points out how even since
the curse was broken their lives have sucked. Snow says, "Emma, the
minute I let go of the belief that things will get better is the minute I
know they won't." That has three different meanings, one of which
amounts to nothing, but I can't think about it too hard or I get dizzy.
When Snow promises Emma they'll find Henry, Rumpy appears and says,
"No you won't." He's already had enough of team work. He's going rogue,
because he wants to succeed. Emma wonders why he thinks she'll fail.
Rumpy says, "How could you not? You don't believe in your parents, or in
magic -- not even yourself." When she argues that she had the faith to
slay a dragon, Rumpy points out she only believes what's been shown to
her. "When have you ever taken a real leap of faith? You know -- the
kind where there's absolutely no proof." Well, there was the time she
kissed her son, saved his life and broke the curse, but Rumpy's
stumping, so he's got no time to listen to me. "I've known you some
time, Miss Swan, and sadly, despite everything you've been through
you're still just a...bail bonds person looking for evidence. Well,
dearie, that's not going to work in Neverland." When Emma insists she'll
do what it takes, Rumpy hisses that she needs someone to tell her what
that is. "Sorry, dearie, our foe is too fearsome for hand-holding.
Neverland is a place where imagination runs wild, and sadly, yours
doesn't." Yeoch. I mean, that's probably true, but ouch. At that he
spins his walking stick and disappears. The stick falls to the deck. We
cut to...
Neverland. As GROAN lights a signal fire, Henry asks if they're
having S'mores because...I guess some of his brains got sucked out by
the portal. Tamara wonders if the empty hand-held communicator was no
accident, because perhaps she ended up with Henry's missing grey matter.
GROAN sneers a warning not to let the kid get in her head. Too late,
dude. She's almost a sentient being, now. Before he can close his mouth,
the group is surrounded by hooded young men. Their leader, Felix
(Parker Croft) announces, "We're the Home Office. Welcome to Neverland."
Tamara is disturbed that the Home Office consists of a bunch of
teenagers. Henry corrects her. "They're the Lost Boys." They want Henry.
Tamara says before they hand him over, they want to know how they're
getting home. Felix reveals they won't get home. When GROAN refuses to
hand over Henry, Felix scoffs. Just then a shadow descends from the
heavens, snatches GROAN's shadow, and flies away with it. GROAN falls to
the ground. He's seemingly dead, but since Once Upon A Time in
Storybrooke he was little, lost boy, Owen, I can't help but wonder
(worry) if we'll see more of him in the future. Seeing GROAN fall,
Tamara orders Henry to run. As she follows, she is struck in the back by
an arrow. Dare I hope at least that she's gone? Clap your hands if you
believe. Commercial.
Henry, hands still bound, runs through the jungle until he falls and
is snatched up by a boy older than he (played by Robbie Kay). We're
supposed to think he's just another fugitive, but I knew right away he
was SPOILER: Peter Pan, so I'm not going to pretend you didn't catch on,
either (although my husband didn't, but in his defense, he was taking a
break from packing for a business trip, and his mind was elsewhere.)
Peter lies to Henry that he is an escaped Lost Boy and says there is no
time for further questions. They have to keep moving. We cut to the...
Jolly Roger. Hook finds Emma below deck. She's doing chin-ups and can
I just say I covet Jennifer Morrison's arms. They're firm, tone,
defined and yet still look soft. Hook gives Emma Baelfire's sword, so
she can prepare for the coming fight. When she says she only knew him as
Neal, Hook pours her a drink and they drink to Neal. We cut to the...
Enchanted Forest. When Neal wakes on Aurora's former funeral bier or
platform, or really uncomfortable bed, he's surrounded by Mulan, Aurora
and Phillip. Upon learning he's in the Enchanted Forest, Neal whispers,
"I'm back." Mulan assumes he's lying, because she recognizes his
clothing as being of the same style and Emma and Snow's. Upon hearing
Emma's name, he asks if she's knows Emma Swan. Mulan deflects and ask
how Neal knows Emma. He gets agitated as he tries to answer and
struggles to sit up. Phillip misdiagnoses Neal's gunshot wound as an
arrow wound and recommends rest. Neal makes a crack about it being a .45
caliber arrow, which goes over like...well, like lead, since his
present company doesn't know from guns. It really is an Enchanted
Forest.
Neal asks for their help. He needs to know Emma and Henry are all
right. Aurora realizes Neal is Henry's father and tells him about how
Snow taught her to navigate the aftereffects of the Sleeping Curse. She
will walk the dream world and try to make contact with his family.
Should she succeed, Aurora wants to know what she should tell Emma. Neal
says, "Tell Emma I'm alive... and that I love her." We cut back to
the...
Jolly Roger. Hook fills Emma in on a little bit of his time with
Baelfire, but their conversation is cut short when the ship begins to
pitch. Up on deck, Regina yells at Snow and Charming, even as they're
trying to steady the ship. When Hook arrives, he grabs the wheel and
orders his makeshift crew to grab any weapon they can find; they're
under attack. You know what's fun for you, and annoying for those around
you? Take a thumb tack, hold it over someone's head and shout, "You're
under a tack!" See, Tubey hired me for my wit. Over screeching sounds
coming from the sea, Emma asks if they're facing a shark. Snow wonders
if it's a whale. Charming asks if it's a kraken. The entire audience
yells, "Unleash the kraken!" Hook says it's worse than that. "Mermaids!"
As Hook tries to outrun the mermaids, Charming declares, "I will not
be capsized by fish," and mans the cannon. Emma and Snow grab a fishing
net and throw it overboard. When they've caught one, Regina is
unimpressed. Having had enough, she unleashes her magical fireballs into
the deep, and chases away the rest of their assailants, then magics the
net back on deck. In it is a nameless mermaid (Natasha Wilson). I'm not
familiar with her work, but she's pretty good at jerking her body like
the proverbial fish out of water. We cut to...

Neverland. Pan leads an unsuspecting Henry through the jungle away
from the Lost Boys. When they take a break, Henry explains that he was
kidnapped by people who work for Pan. Pan says, "If Pan wants you, he
will get you." When Henry asks his supposed fellow fugitive if he is
wanted by Pan, Pan lies that he stole pixie dust so he could try home,
but it wouldn't work. When Pan pretends to despair at their situation,
Henry encourages his not to lose hope and asks where they can hide. Pan
says they can hide in the Echo Caves, if only they can get there. Henry
tells him to lead the way. We cut to the...
Enchanted Forest. Neal fills Mulan in on portal travel and the land
without magic. He tells her that her legend had made it over there.
"They made a movie about you. It's pretty good." Mulan deadpans, "What's
a movie?" Neal is at a loss for words, but his awkward moment is cut
short when Aurora awakens and reports she failed to make contact with
anyone in her dreams. Cue Tchaikovsky. Neal is certain his father must
have left something behind that he could use to contact Emma. He just
has to get to his castle. Phillip asks, "Who's your father?" Voice grim,
Neal says, "Rumpelstiltskin." We cut to...
Neverland. Rumpy finds Tamara, who I am sad to report is still alive.
He magically removes the arrow from her back and asks her where Henry
is. Finally free from pain, Tamara tells Rumpy that she told Henry to
run, because Pan is after him and was behind all of this. She confesses
she didn't know for whom she was working and says she's sorry about
Neal. Crouching down beside her, Rumpy acknowledges Tamara was only a
pawn. She asks if he can forgive her. Oh Rumpy, I often root for your
redemption, but right now, I feel like praying a modified version of St.
Augustine's, "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet." Never one
to disappoint, Rumpy keeps his voice low and gentle, answers, "No,"
rips Tamara's heart out of her chest, and crushes it to dust. Hurrah!
Commercial.
Jolly Roger. Hook and Charming think they need to throw the mermaid
back into the sea, but Regina wants a hostage. As this unlikely team
debates the usefulness of this plan (Regina, of course, wastes no time
suggesting torture), the mermaid grabs her conch shell and blows into it
to sound a warming. "Let me go, or die." We cut to the...
Enchanted Forest. Mulan is leading Neal across an arid stretch that
could be the remains of Lake Nostos, as he admits he doesn't know how to
explain what a movie is. Um, it is pictures that move, such that you're
looking at something play out as if it's happening before your eyes,
Neal. I think you could give her a bare bones explanation. Mulan must
smell the incompetence oozing from him, so she asks why Emma never
mentioned him when she was in the Enchanted Forest. Neal confesses he
broke Emma's heart. "I let her go so that she could break the curse and
fulfill her destiny. When it was broken, I could have gone after her. I
could have told her I loved her, but I was afraid she would never
forgive me, so I wound up taking the easy way out -- which is not
trying." Mulan decides to play Neal-Apologist in chief. "Your belief in
love wasn't strong enough to overcome your fear of rejection." Neal
appreciates the assist and piles it on a little thicker. "Greatest
regret of my life. Not one I'd wish upon anyone." Nice try writers, but
it's even worse than that. He let her go to prison for crimes
HE
committed. He should have convinced August to go with him and tell Emma
about her destiny and then leave the decision to believe them or not in
her hands. She might have laughed them off as con men, but at least then
they would have done their best. That's what really happened. Still,
Mulan is touched by his sob story. We cut to the...
Jungle. With the Lost Boys hot on their trail, Henry and Pan continue to run. We cut to the...
Jolly Roger. The crew argues about how to get the mermaid to talk.
Just knowing these characters, you know who is in favor of compassion
and who isn't. The mermaid isn't having any of it, though and demands to
be freed. Regina says if they free the mermaid, she will return with
her friends to kill them. Since Regina easily chased them off with
fireballs I'm not sure why she, in particular, is worried about their
return. The mermaid says she and her friends don't need to kill them,
they'll do it on their own, then again demands her freedom. Lightning
strikes. A storm bursts. Hook says they have to hold onto the mermaid
as leverage. Charming draws a sword, holds it to the mermaid's throat
and demands that she stop the storm. Regina pats him on the back and
tells him, "Now, filet the bitch." Charming mightn't be the brightest
bulb on the Christmas tree, but he knows when Regina's his cheering
squad he'd better try again. He backs off and says they're not
barbarians.
Hook turns the ship to try to outrun the storm. As Snow and Regina
bicker, the storm intensifies. Emma tries to get everyone to stop and
think things through. Declaring he already has, Regina waves her hand
and the mermaid turns to wood. The weather worsens. A monster wave bears
down on the Jolly Roger. Emma yells, "Regina, what did you do? What
have you done?" With Ethan Embry's GROAN is still in my mind, I want
desperately to tell one of these characters that they're doing, "
That Thing You Do."
Emma's questions are the closest I've gotten, but it still feels like
too much of a reach, so I'm confessing here, in hopes of ridding myself
of the
earworm. Anyhow, everyone grabs hold of the rigging and the water washes over them. Commercial.
Enchanted Forest. Rumpy's Estate. Once inside the drawing room, Mulan
says it looks abandoned. Neal spies a goblet, dips his finger, tastes
the wine and realizes someone is there. Is it just my eyes, or is this
whole room computer generated? I don't remember it all looking like that
during the Rumpy/Belle flashbacks (although maybe the library was). Oh
well, while I've been wondering about nonsense, Neal and Mulan have been
discovered. An arrow lands in the wall about two inches in front of
Neal's face. Mulan draws her weapon. An entirely new Robin Hood (now
played by
Sean Maguire),
having makes his presence known, introduces himself as Robin. Neal
realizes he's Robin Hood. Robin asks why they're trespassing in his
castle. Mulan argues that it's the Dark One's. Robin says the Dark One
has been missing since the Queen cast her curse. Neal says Robin is
welcome to the castle, he just needs to look around for a bit. When
Robin asks, Neal introduces himself as Baelfire and says he's the Dark
One's son. Robin figures no one would lie about that so he lowers his
bow and give Neal leave to continue his search. They talk about Robin's
previous confrontation with the Dark One, who eventually spared his
life.
Neal explains he's looking for a magical item in the now looted room.
Spotting his father's old, rough-hewn staff on the floor, he picks it
up. Mulan wonders how it could be magical at all. Neal says it's his
father's and points out the notches Rumpy etched to mark his son's
growth, then swings it around. The magic uncloaks a hidden cupboard. The
stick is enchanted with blood magic, which is how Neal is able to wield
it while Robin or any other looter could not. As Neal approaches the
cabinet, we cut to the...
Jolly Roger. As the argument between Regina and Snow intensifies, so
does the storm. There are a lot of accusations of life ruining and the
women trade blows. Charming and Hook insert themselves and are soon
squaring off against each other. Manning the wheel, solo, Emma looks
from the raging sea to her fell crew members and realizes, "It's not the
mermaids, it's us." No one listens, so she screams that if they don't
stop fighting they're going to die. They're causing the very storm that
will take their lives. When the refuse to listen, Emma climbs up on the
ship's rail and dives into the ocean. The gang stops fighting long
enough to shout after her and look overboard. Just then, a piece of
rigging lets go. A heavy metal pulley (I guess) falls into the drink
behind her and hits her on the head. The crew gasps. We cut to...
Neverland. Pan and Henry find themselves boxed in at a cliff's edge.
Henry snatches the pixie dust from the lanyard around Pan's neck and
says it's their way out. Since pixie dust will make them fly, all they
have to do is believe. Pan lies that he can't believe. Henry has enough
faith for both of them. He sprinkles them with the dust, grabs Pan,
jumps off the cliff and the fly off into commercial.
Jolly Roger. Snow screams as Emma disappears under the water, then
begs Regina to magic Emma back on board, but Regina says (and might even
mean it when she does) that she can't. Since she can't see Emma,
"...I'll just bring up water and half her leg." Charming is ready to
jump overboard, but Hook realizes he'll drown too, so he ties a rope
around our dashing prince, so he can pull him back to safety. Under
water, Charming finally finds Emma, grabs her and brings her to the
surface. Hook, Regina and Snow work together to fish father and daughter
out of the drink. Emma is unconscious until she coughs up water, to the
delight of her parents and companions. The clouds dissipate. The moon
appears. Still breathless, Emma smiles and looks at them, eyes wide. "I
told you." We cut to...
Neverland. In the jungle, Rumpy casually strolls until he finds a
place to sit and beckons, "Come out and say hello, dearie." Felix
appears and tells Rumpy that Pan welcomes him to stay as long as he'd
like with one caveat. If Rumpy is there for the boy, that will make him
Pan's enemy. "If you go against him, you will not survive." Rumpy
laughs. "The question isn't, 'will I survive', because we both know I
won't. No, no. The real question is how many of you I take with me."
Felix asks if that's his answer. Rumpy confirms it, so Felix promises to
see him again in less friendly circumstances. Walking away, Rumpy says,
"Count on it." Felix calls after him, "One last thing. There's
something he wanted you to have." He throws a straw doll at Rumpy's
feet. It's clothed in blue. Rumpy stoops to pick it up. Tears fill his
eyes. Felix crouches so they're eye-to-eye and says, "Isn't it funny?
The things we haven't thought about in years still have the ability to
make us cry." He laughs as Rumpy softly sobs, then takes his leave. Am I
supposed to remember that doll? I didn't get a chance to read our
boards this week. Was that once Bae's doll? Was it Rumpy's? Do we know? I
sure don't. We cut to the...
Enchanted Forest. Rumpy's Castle. Neal opens the now unhidden
cupboard and scans its cobwebbed contents until he finds what looks to
be a snow globe, but is actually a crystal ball. After a bitter laugh
that how he spent his life running from magic only to realize it's now
the only thing that can help him, he lays his hands on the ball and
closes his eyes. It fills with magical smoke, but when the smoke clears,
the ball is empty. Neal picks it up and asks why it's not working.
Mulan advises that he not think of a place, and instead think of Emma.
When Neal tries again, it works. He sees Emma in the middle of a jungle,
and says, "Oh, no. It can't be. [...] That's not Storybrooke. Emma's in
Neverland. We cut to...
Neverland. Now ashore, Regina says they can still carry out Hook's
planned sneak attack, but Emma realizes it's too late. Pan must know
they're there. "It's time we stopped running. Gold was right. This land
is run on belief. All of us have been too busy being at each others'
throats to be believers. I was as wrong as anyone else. It's time for
all of us to believe -- not in magic, but in each other." Regina can't
believe Emma thinks they can be friends after all that has passed. Emma
clarifies that she's not talking about friendship. "I know there's a lot
of history here and a lot of hate." Hook butts in. "Actually, I quite
fancy you from time to time when you're not yelling at me." Emma ignores
the flirtatious attempt and continues. "We don't need to be friends.
What we need to know is the only way to get Henry back is cooperation."What an effective, engaging, emotional premiere. I find myself believing
in season 3. I'm still getting back into the recap swing, so I'm going
to stop here, and savor the good taste 5.1 has left in my mouth. I'll
see you Monday morning with my review of episode 5.2, "Lost Girl." You
believe me, don't you? Just clap your hands and say you believe.